Notice:
The advice given on this site is based upon individual or quoted experience, yours may differ.
The Officers, Staff and members of this site only provide information based upon the concept that anyone utilizing this information does so at their own risk and holds harmless all contributors to this site.
Now that I have a new keel winch and cable, I'd like to know how best to leave the keel for the winter. Leave some slack and rest the keel on a stand, or keep it up and tight?
Not sure how/where your boat is stored, but for our second winter, the keel was full up and the yard must have set the boat down too hard before putting in the jack stands, resulting in a pin-hole puncture in the storage cavity right above where the cable connects to the keel, which was noticable only once launched in the spring. We were taking on about 1.5 gallons per day...had to pull the boat and have the repair done...the yard of course took no responsibility...now we store the boat w/ the keel about 12" below the hull...allows for inspection, cable replacement and keeps the yard from bouncing the boat when setting it down...
I don't think I have ever seen any make sailboat with a swinger in my yard without the keel lowered onto some blocks and with zero tension on the cable.
If I had a swinger and was having her lifted out, I would make sure to admonish the yard NOT TO SET HER DOWN ON THE KEEL! Once the hull is blocked, I'd lower the keel onto a block, to take maybe 1000 lbs. off the contact points on the hull, depending on the angle of the keel. (It weighs around 200 lbs. more in air than in water.)
My fin keel C-25 was mostly supported by the keel itself--the stands were essentially just to keep her upright, so there was little pressure from them.
Set the boat on jack stands tall enough to lower the keel onto a support block. Let the block support the keel weight. Then take up any slack just slightly in the cable. Make sure the wraps on the keel winch are straight. As stated above, NEVER let the yard lower the boat onto the swing keel.
Thanks to all for your advice. In years past, the boat rested on stands, with a block supporting the keel which was in the full up and locked position. I will be sure to lower it this year and take some tension of the winch and cable.
...In years past, the boat rested on stands, with a block supporting the keel which was in the full up and locked position.
The problem with that is it implies the boat is being at least partially supported by the keel, which can damage the keel trunk. A swinger should be supported only by the hull, and the keel should support only itself.
Good to hear Dave. I have a fin keel and I was not sure what the ratios of support between the keel and stands should be. For trailer or haul out. Sounds like keel can provide a little more support than I thought.
My boat sits on its fin keel when on the trailer. The rollers only prevent it tipping over, though they do add some support to the hull. I don't have a cradle. I would say common sense dictates that a swing keel should not be supporting the boat, or hanging on its cable, when out of the water. As Dave noted, the weight of the keel will be substantially more when the boat's on the hard. I wouldn't trust any yard to do the job right unless I knew the staff well, and was sure they were experienced in handling my type of boat.
Notice: The advice given on this site is based upon individual or quoted experience, yours may differ. The Officers, Staff and members of this site only provide information based upon the concept that anyone utilizing this information does so at their own risk and holds harmless all contributors to this site.