Notice:
The advice given on this site is based upon individual or quoted experience, yours may differ.
The Officers, Staff and members of this site only provide information based upon the concept that anyone utilizing this information does so at their own risk and holds harmless all contributors to this site.
<font size=5></font id=size5>Just had to say it. The 3rd gen rudder finally made my 250 (#338) the boat I thought I was buying. I can finally balance the boat and go for miles with the tiller positioned with nothing more than the tiller extension resting against the side of the cockpit. Also my kids can again help at the helm (we had a c22/sk for years) without complaining about how hard it is to hold on course. If the 250 was a car we should have all been given the 3rd gen as NTSB recall. Thanks to all those on this site who I'm sure helped influence Catalina. And yes thanks Catalina for doing something about it.
Love the new rudder! <img src=icon_smile.gif border=0 align=middle>
Just read your 3rd Gen Rudder and was wondering is it (the 3rd generation) a beaching rudder? I'm in need of a good beaching rudder as the 2nd generation I have still doesn't do the job in a strong breeze. Also any ideas of how to decrease weather helm in a C-250 water ballast other than reefing the main sail?
it is not a beaching rudder, but if you install it properly (and assuming your transom gear allows enough clearance), it can be easily removed.
i found that the 3rd gen rudder greatly reduced weather helm, or at least the "feeling" of weather helm, since its action is so light compared to the 1st generation, that imho should have NEVER been shipped.
My WB boat came with the new rudder from the factory. While not what you would normally consider a "beaching rudder," it extends no further below the bottom of the hull than the centerboard does when fully retracted. When approaching the shallows, I pull up the centerboard and if it clears, the rudder takes care of itself. Works great!
Sorry, I can't figure out how to post a photo on the forum, but email me if you're interested and I can email you a photo of my boat on her trailer which will give you some idea of how the rudder hangs in relation to the rest of the boat.
Bren Peterson C250WB, #642, "Ruah" San Antonio, TX
"While not what you would normally consider a "beaching rudder," it extends no further below the bottom of the hull than the centerboard does when fully retracted." - Bren Peterson
According to the spec's for the WB 250, the draft with the board up is 1'8". Surely the rudder must extend further down than that and from the picture it looks like it does. I believe the rudder on my C25 extends 3 feet below the waterline, but my first boat was a swinger with a kick up rudder and on a few ocassions I was extremely thankful that it did what it was designed to do. I shudder to think what the damage would have been if I hit something at speed with a fixed rudder.
Brad.... the 2nd generation beaching can be balanced pretty well by following instructions in tech tips...makes a world of a difference... and retains the beaching rudder... or, go to the third generation... don't fight the 2nd generation as is without mods.
The drawing in your post is still from the C250 brochure showing the older rudder. Incredibly, the new rudder really does not extend below the centerboard when retracted. I don't even have to unship it when trailering. They made up for the lack of depth by increasing the chord (width) of the rudder instead.
I'll try once again to post a couple of pictures of my boat on her trailer below. Having trouble with this URL thing. Fortunately I sail better than I compute!<img src=icon_smile.gif border=0 align=middle>
Wow! Can't believe I got these pics on here! You are right however about not wanting to hit anything with the fixed rudder. I depower the sails VERY early when approaching a shallow area and motor in so if the centerboard does start to touch, I can hopefully reverse quickly enough to avoid dinging the rudder. So far, hasn't been a problem.
Bren Peterson C250WB, #642, "Ruah" San Antonio, TX
I hate to burst your bubble, but the rest of us aren't able to see your photos. I have been messing with this for about an hour, and I haven't figured out why your photos aren't working. Right now my best guess is that the URL address isn't quite right ... either that, or the MSN site you are using doesn't work with our Forum software.
I signed up with MSN Passport, created a "group," and I posted a photo there. I put it in the "Test" section, and I can see the photo, but I don't know if the rest of the group can. Please check the photo for me and let me know if you can see it ... if so, that will prove that MSN is compatible with our Forum software, and we will be one step closer to figuring out why your photos aren't working.
Thanks, Don ... I'll do some more experimenting with the size. For now, I'm stumped trying to figure out Bren's problem ... it's got to be the URL address I suppose.
Well, I tried to make the photo larger, but so far nothing has worked.
Bren, I don't know how "attached" you are to your MSN Passport site, but you might want to consider "Shutterfly" ... it's free, and it works with our Forum. Here is a link:
Thanks for the infor. Kind of busy today, but will try the "shutterfly" thing tonight if I can. Strange that no one else can see my photos. They appear nice and big whenever I log onto the forum. Why would they only show up on my machine? That's OK, I like me here in my own little world!<img src=icon_smile_wink.gif border=0 align=middle>
Just kidding, I'll try to fix the problem. I've rechecked the URL and it matches what is listed for the photos, which as you mentioned, I had 'uploaded' to my MSN Passport files.
BTW, I checked your test and also can see the pic but very small. Thanks for your help.
Bren Peterson C250WB, #642, "Ruah" San Antonio, TX
7:20pm Buzz,
I edited the previous post with the pictures via a "shuuterfly" upload. I can see the pictures, but they are really small, as earlier when I used the MSN URL they showed up nice and big on my computer. Do you see the edited version or is it still not coming through? Thanks again for helping my figure this out.
Thanks for the infor. Kind of busy today, but will try the "shutterfly" thing tonight if I can. Strange that no one else can see my photos. They appear nice and big whenever I log onto the forum. Why would they only show up on my machine?
Bren Peterson C250WB, #642, "Ruah" San Antonio, TX
7:20pm Buzz,
I edited the previous post with the pictures via a "shuuterfly" upload. I can see the pictures, but they are really small, as earlier when I used the MSN URL they showed up nice and big on my computer. Do you see the edited version or is it still not coming through? Thanks again for helping my figure this out. <hr height=1 noshade id=quote></BLOCKQUOTE id=quote></font id=quote><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica" size=2 id=quote>
Hi Bren,
This is all a mystery to me ... I don't know why the photos are so small, but I guess we are making some progress (at least we can see your photos now). I think we might have more luck enlarging them with Shutterfly than MSN ... I could only find options to make the photos smaller in MSN.
I am out of town right now ... I'll play with it when I get home and see what I can figure out.
How does a person determine what generation of rudder is provided. My 250 WK has a deep rudder that appears to be about the same depth as the keel. Which is the second problem. Last year I had an unfortunate encounter with a submerged rock. The keel did take a hit but the unfortunate occurrence was that he rudder was knocked off. Now for the difficult lessons, you cannot steer the C250WK with the outboard motor. The boat will fishtail back and forth will no real control. Fortunately a commercial towboat was nearby and I called for an assist. The towboat could not tow me up the channel safely, same problem, the 250 just yawed back and forth. A second towboat was called to provide drag.
A beaching rudder would have saved the day. The rock encounter was a straight on hit. Once the keel cleared the rock the rudder was just sheared off. Just a few inches would have saved the rudder. So my interest is that if the 3rd generation rudder is even slightly shorter than my production rudder, it may well be worth the investment.
Jack, If you look on the "Swap Meet" part of this forum, you'll see that I'm selling my Cat 250 "Kick up Beaching rudder". It would certainly solve the destoyed rudder issue because if you hit anything the rudder simply kicks up, and you reset it to get it back down after the obstruction.......check it out, I even reffered to a picture in the forum "tech tips" so you can see what it looks like
Jack, you seem to describe having a 2nd generation rudder. The third is shorter...and (I think) is designed to be near the depth of the wing keel.
The kickup that is available would solve your problems... but would only be a choice if it has the 2nd generation rudder with it. The first generation rudder has inadequate lift. The 2nd can be balanced in the kick up version.
The 3rd is available at a very good price as Catalina is providing at cost.... It is available only in blade form.
Now....some comments about your motoring without the rudder. It has been my contention for several years now that the c250 could benefit from some skeg. I expect this is a touchy issue as all issues are that alter the basic design of a boat as it gets into one design issues and how they affect racing.
I do not plan to race my boat... and have added a small skeg to my center board model. The way in which I did it was quite simple and was done in a matter of a couple of hours.
I used a piece of dense shipping foam 4 ft long for a test and still have it on the boat three years later as I installed it. My plan was to glass it... but it still looks good....but my boat doesn't stay in the water and has no bottom paint.
I simply formed the shape of a skeg, marked where it would be located...masked off the bottom...sprayed 3M adhesive to hull and foam and stuck it on...and its stayed there for over a thousand miles of sailing so far and remains looking like the day it was installed.
My reason for adding.... was that my boat once into a rudder lock turn...was very difficult to pull out of. This was made somewhat better by balancing the rudder... but I felt the boat needed increased tracking stability. I don't think my close turning has been compromised much but a skeg has to be thought of as a compromise between turning ability and tracking.
Of course, if your a racer...the skeg wouldn't be an option due to one design requirements and perhaps wouldn't be wanted due to possible increased drag.
Prior to the addition of the skeg... the auto pilot couldn't perform auto tacks as it didn't have enough torque to pull out of the turns. Admittedly...I did the wrong thing in modifying the rudder and adding the skeg at the same time so that I'm not sure which contributed the most or perhaps even all...to solving the problems of pulling out of the turns... what is known...is there is no problem now pulling out of hard rudder lock turns either under motor or sailing. I briefly discussed the skeg with Catalina...and they discounted a need for it... I'm not so sure...and happy enough now with the handling...that I'm not taking it off.
Just received my 3rd-Gen rudder. FYI, it now comes with NOTHING (just the fiberglass blade) and costs $195 (which they tell me is still a great discount considering that the normal price would be somewhere around $570.
They asked me several times whether the boat was wing or water so apparently the rudders are different for the two. Does anyone know what the difference is?
The parts man told me that I could use my old pintals, instead of buying new ones ($30). After seeing the picture in TechTips I now realize that that was totally wrong. The beaching rudder doesn't have any of the same parts.
Can someone who has done this tell me if I need something different to move my old tiller from the aluminum rudder-head to this new blade? (Also, doesn't the up-down movement of the metal on the tiller cause the new rudder to become marred?
Thanks for your thoughts. Barry Dorfman Ten Forward C250wk #368
Arlyn - Thanks for your response. Good information and I appreciate your comments. I have ordered the 3rd Gen Rudder from Catalina. I'll install the new 3rd Gen. rudder and save the old one for a spare, maybe convert to a kick up version. One never knows, if I happen to pop off another rudder at least I'll have a back-up.
Your suggestion of providing a skeg to the keel is very interesting. As a simple safty issue, a lost rudder should not make a boat un-towable. I never thought about it before the accident. I just assumed a sailboat would track another boat fairly good even with a lost rudder. Not so!!!Sorry about the late response, but this is the time of year when us folks up north are trying to get as much sailing in as possible.
<BLOCKQUOTE id=quote><font size=1 face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica" id=quote>quote:<hr height=1 noshade id=quote> does anyone else but me think that ther shoud be another forum for the 250 wb, seperate from the 250 wk. they are two entirely different boats and nothing is the same between the two? we start to read a comment from someone, only to realize we are talking about two entirely seperate boats, we really have nothing in common. <hr height=1 noshade id=quote></BLOCKQUOTE id=quote></font id=quote><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica" size=2 id=quote>
I would respectfully disagree. The C250 water WB & WK are different, but so do the C25 swing, wing, & fin which share a forum. There are many similarities in equipment, etc w/ all the C250 models. What would be most helpful would be for posters to include their model in their signature block. There are so few C250s that I think it would dilute the exchange of info to fracture the class into more forums.
Notice: The advice given on this site is based upon individual or quoted experience, yours may differ. The Officers, Staff and members of this site only provide information based upon the concept that anyone utilizing this information does so at their own risk and holds harmless all contributors to this site.