Catalina - Capri - 25s International Assocaition Logo(2006)  
Assn Members Area · Join
Association Forum
Association Forum
Home | Profile | Register | Active Topics | Forum Users | Search | FAQ
Username:
Password:
Save Password
Forgot your Password?

 All Forums
 Catalina/Capri 25/250 Sailor's Forums
 Catalina 250 Specific Forum
 waterballast vs. wingkeel
 New Topic  Topic Locked
 Printer Friendly
Author Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  

Mehmet
Deckhand

Member Avatar

2 Posts

Initially Posted - 09/16/2002 :  04:14:15  Show Profile
Dear all,

I am new on your forum. I am intending to buy a Catalina 250 as soon as I sell my present boat.
I need your comments on above matter. Concerning the sailing performance which one is better: waterballast or wing keel.
I will use the boat for bluewatersailing and not tow it at all.

Thank you in advance for your contribution.

Mehmet Atay


Edited by - on

ssteakley
Captain

Members Avatar

USA
467 Posts

Response Posted - 09/16/2002 :  06:13:58  Show Profile
Mehmet,
you can look back in the previous pages and see lots of discussion regarding this question. But, if yoy are not going to trailor than choose the wing keel. No water ballest to fill and maintain, more headroom in the cabin. I am sure each has it's own sailing characteristics. If yuo talk to a person with a wing keel they love how their boat sails and the same for a person with a wing Keel. But if you think that you will keep and trailor the boat even a few times......consider the water ballest, The wing Keel is not really a "trailorable" boat in my opinion,
Steve Steakley
Moon Chaser 250WK #385


Edited by - on
Go to Top of Page

Mehmet
Deckhand

Members Avatar

2 Posts

Response Posted - 09/16/2002 :  08:57:27  Show Profile
Dear Steve,

Thank you for your advise; I will check previous posts. What I wonder is wether the sailing ability varies due to differnt center of gravity. Actually gross weights are different; this might be because of eliminitaing this differentiation by the designer.

Regards

Mehmet


Edited by - on
Go to Top of Page

pjagur
Deckhand

Members Avatar

USA
4 Posts

Response Posted - 10/14/2002 :  18:15:02  Show Profile  Visit pjagur's Homepage
<BLOCKQUOTE id=quote><font size=1 face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica" id=quote>quote:<hr height=1 noshade id=quote>
The wing Keel is not really a "trailorable" boat in my opinion,
<hr height=1 noshade id=quote></BLOCKQUOTE id=quote></font id=quote><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica" size=2 id=quote>
Steve - I'm only hanging out here for a couple of days but since we have local C250WK owners that trailer at the drop of a hat and range some 1100 miles from home every year I though I'd ask why do you feel that way.

Phil Agur
s/v Wing Tip
C270 LE #184
http://www.catalinayachts.org/Fleet4/wingtip/mvc-736x.jpg


Edited by - on
Go to Top of Page

Arlyn Stewart
Master Marine Consultant

Members Avatar

USA
2984 Posts

Response Posted - 10/15/2002 :  09:41:54  Show Profile
Though we really have not had an expert (some one who has sailed both models)to critique the differences, there are some perspectives about the sailing characteristics between the two boats.

It's surmised that the center board boat weathers a bit better but that the wing with its lighter discplacement does better off wind. Its thought that the center board is a little easier to balance the helm as the center board can be raked aft.

The center board boat was designed for trailering... and does that really well. To accomplish the easy trailering, a water ballast hull with retractable center board are employed. For those who don't trailer, there is little question that to avoid these unessary systems for a fixed keel is the better route to go... I would think this especially true for a salt water environment.

There are those who trailer the wing version but it requires more effort. They will either do a "rope launch" or boat lift. The tow is an additional 900 lbs with the boat sitting higher on the trailer.

A water ballast boat can be launched and retreived without tongue extension on just about any ramp used for power boating.

This can become a big issue... for example, when I haul from Texas to the Great Lakes to cruise, I like to put in at a municipal harbor at Harrisville,Mi. I have family there who serve as my crew and it makes it very convenient to launch and retrieve there. The ramp would not launch a wing keel and there is no lift there.

Happy to see visitors to the forum.... yall are always welcome.

Arlyn C-250 W/B #224

Edited by - on
Go to Top of Page

dlucier
Master Marine Consultant

Members Avatar

Virgin Islands (United Kingdom)
7583 Posts

Response Posted - 10/15/2002 :  18:41:37  Show Profile
Arlyn,

In a previous thread on water ballast systems, you wrote,

<b>"To assist the interior ballast (with its shorter righting arm....the arm distance is increased by (squaring the bilges) a flatter and wider bottom which serves two purposes... It places the water ballast wider from the center line...and it provides increased form stability.

There are trade offs for the benefits... among them, the wider flatter hull form is subject to increased weather helm with heel. To increase righting stability, freeboard is increased by doing away with the sidedecks but subjects the boat to more windage."</b>

My question is, "Do both the wing keel and water ballast models share the same hull shape or does Catalina have a different hull form for each model?"






Don Lucier, 'North Star'
1980 C25 #2151
SR/FK

Edited by - on
Go to Top of Page

Arlyn Stewart
Master Marine Consultant

Members Avatar

USA
2984 Posts

Response Posted - 10/16/2002 :  09:47:09  Show Profile
My answer is a guess... that they use the same hull form.

Some history... The late 80's and early 90's were very sluggish times for the yacht industry. The surcharge the government had put on yachts, the economy and perhaps other factors played into this. Shoal draft hulls had been some of Catalina and McGregors best sellers. There were 6,000 C25's produced and near 20,000 C22's. Used boats were relatively cheap and easy to find... it was getting difficult to sell a new boat.

The answer was new designs. Something the used market couldn't offer. In part, that was seen as a replacement for the swing keel which had to be dropped because of safety concerns. It had been Catalina's hottest seller. The powerful sedan capable of towing large boats was gone. Roger McGregor introduced the water ballast concept and Frank Butler and others fighting to find sales.... followed.

The C250 was designed specifically as a center board water ballast boat... initially, water ballast was slow to gain acceptance and the hoped for sales were sluggish. Cruising world had snubbed water ballast. Inadequate rudders on almost all models left them with handling problems. A stigma against water ballast existed. Even my dealer....in '95 when I ordered my boat, tried to steer me away from it... suggesting a new C22.

But, the c250 offered something that the used market didn't have... a large enough boat for cruising for a couple of weeks, a good tandem axle trailer capable of long hauls, easy to haul with a half ton pickup and easy to settup and launch even single handed....

While my need for a boat to haul from Texas to the Great Lakes each summer was met... settup time of a 25 foot boat just doesn't work for most sailors and with sales sluggish, Catalina introduced the C250 wing somewhere arround hull # 230. I've talked with Bill Holcomb about this, and if my memory serves me correct...he said that the C25 was dropped from their offering, due to a fire destroying the mold... and as they had aquired Capri and the 26', it was thought for some time to fill the need for a mid 20's boat. Remember, money was very tight in the yacht business about then.

Why have I offered all this history to the simple question, "are the hulls the same?" It's my belief that if Catalina had been designing a wing keel 25 footer, they would not have chosen the hull form of the C250 which met the specific need of an internally ballasted boat but had an undesirable trade off... fairly severe weather helm at greater heeling angles. Molds are a major investment however, and the addition of a wing keel to the existing design wasn't near as difficult or expensive as a new design and new molds.

There were some other issues involved...a major one is always, the perceived need... which seemed to be moving away from racing towards family sailing... many of them new to sailing who wouldn't care as much about the lack of salty lines and teak as about the easy swim access and spacious interior.

If one wants classic looks, and a fast boat with great handling, the Capri 26 is a better choice. Given all the variables...its easy to understand and appreciate why Catalina made the decision to offer the c250 wing without a redesign.

Last, I think also, Catalina believed the wing on the c250 hull had some great possibilities. With the additional righting arm of the hull, a wing keel ought to really handle some canvas. The tall rig with a 150 headsail was part of that vision... which of course we know had to be dropped.

What seems evident is that the hull form of the c250 is near the length to width ratio limits. Doing so... makes it a spacious family cruiser capable of being easily haulded down the road... but leaves it a little unforgiving to "lead" balance. And, there's a little irony here... it's a boat often sailed by newer sailors knowing little about the intrinsics of helm balance compared to many more experienced sailors who sail boats with forgiving helms.





Arlyn C-250 W/B #224

Edited by - on
Go to Top of Page

dlucier
Master Marine Consultant

Members Avatar

Virgin Islands (United Kingdom)
7583 Posts

Response Posted - 10/16/2002 :  12:38:57  Show Profile
Arlyn, Wow! You've done your research! Thanks for the information and the history lesson. <img src=icon_smile.gif border=0 align=middle>

Don Lucier, 'North Star'
1980 C25 #2151
SR/FK

Edited by - on
Go to Top of Page

bren737
Captain

Members Avatar

291 Posts

Response Posted - 10/16/2002 :  16:53:40  Show Profile
Greeting all. . .

I was on the phone to Catalina about something today and had just read your post, Arlyn. I was curious about the 250s (WB and WK) coming from the same mold, yet the WK having more freeboard than the WB. Since I had him on the phone I asked David Krauss (250 tech support) about it and after double-checking with Frank, he called me back and reported this:

The 250 WB and WK do share the same basic hull form in regard to wetted surface (waterline down), with the obvious subtle differences at the centerboard trunk/keel fairing. However, since the additional stability of the lead keel allows for a higher cabin top (and freeboard) they do not actually come from the same mold. There is one production mold each for the WK and WB. All boats built come from these respective molds. The deck/cabin tops are the same and come from the same mold for both models. The difference in freeboard is plus four inches on the WK. He said the additional cabin headroom in the WK results from a combination of the higher deck/cabin top (resulting from the additional freeboard) and the lower floor (resulting from the lack of a water ballast tank).

Mark Melchoir's web site (www.texassailor.com) has a great 'trip report' from his visit a couple of years ago to the factory. Look under "My c250" and then "Catalina Factory Tour". Hope I can make it there someday!<img src=icon_smile.gif border=0 align=middle>

Bren Peterson
C250WB, #642, "Ruah"
San Antonio, TX

Edited by - on
Go to Top of Page

Dave Bristle
Master Marine Consultant

Members Avatar

Djibouti
10005 Posts

Response Posted - 10/23/2002 :  15:13:42  Show Profile
VERY interesting, Bren... That puts to rest a lot of speculation from over the years. I figured the headroom came only from the lack of the tanks, and that the added freeboard came from the slightly lower displacement. (Some of it must, however.) I could see separate molds for the keel/CB attachments, but I would have never guessed the hull was taller on one of them.

Dave Bristle - 1985 C-25 #5032 SR-FK-Dinette-Honda "Passage" in SW CT

Edited by - on
Go to Top of Page
  Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  
 New Topic  Topic Locked
 Printer Friendly
Jump To:
Association Forum © since 1999 Catalina Capri 25s International Association Go To Top Of Page
Powered By: Snitz Forums 2000 Version 3.4.06
Notice: The advice given on this site is based upon individual or quoted experience, yours may differ.
The Officers, Staff and members of this site only provide information based upon the concept that anyone utilizing this information does so at their own risk and holds harmless all contributors to this site.