Notice:
The advice given on this site is based upon individual or quoted experience, yours may differ.
The Officers, Staff and members of this site only provide information based upon the concept that anyone utilizing this information does so at their own risk and holds harmless all contributors to this site.
I have WB#065 and have had 6 annual keel wire failures while keeping the boat on a mooring since I purchased the boat new - the last one was two weeks ago. I have had an informal review of the problem by Frank Butler and Jerry Douglas and a formal "upgrade" from both which did not solve the problem. I have just returned the boat to my dealer and am now "discussing" replacment of this boat. Has anyone else experienced these kinds of problems? After the first failure responses to my inquirey on this site said to fully raise the board while on its mooring and to make certain that the slack was taken out of the line while the board is down. Jerry Douglas also confirmed this and I have followed this very carefully but still had all fo these failures. Please note that the failures did not occur from launching the boat nor from running it aground, etc. The baot sits on a mooring in 5' of water and would fail after about 5 times of lowering and raising the keel over a Summer sailing season.
Skip, I have hull #085 ( 1995) have never had a failure, nor needed to replace the cable at all. Sounds like an anomaly in how either the rigging was set up at the factory, or some other sheave fitting was glassed in off-center. Since you've documented this so well, you may have a case with the dealer. ( Does the lemon-law work with boats ?)
I am wondering if raising the board too tight contributes to the problem. Specifically in regards to Gclarks comments, variation may be an issue, and a center board that raises a little off center may be more vulnerable as it then loads the cable against the outer and sharp edge of the sheave.
Related to this...adding shims on the pivot shaft greatly reduce the center board clatter and possibly may reduce movement of the cable against the ridge on the sheave which in my opinion seems to be the cutting culprit.
Catalina needs to fix this design flaw. This kind of thing is unacceptable given the purchase price of the boat. If this was happening to Ford/Chevy owners, there would be a major recall. Why should Catalina be any different? The company's lack of response to my complaints has nearly guaranteed that I will never buy another Catalina. It is only a matter of time before I move up to a bigger boat, and Catalina has made it clear that my future business is not wanted.
In fairness to Catalina, they have tried some changes to the cable system...the original used a termination similar to that on the backstay bridle... this was changed to a ball and clevis termination.
Mine has broken twice....the second time due to my hitting a rock with the keel (it was up). The fix this time was to use a cable termination into the clevis bought at the home center. It consist of a round section about 3/8" in diameter with hole in cross section and then two set screws coming from the two sides. Seemed to work great...and the advantage is that it can be used with the old cable as it had plenty of length.
With all the problems that you C250 owners have with the steering, the rudder, the outboard, the centerboard etc. - are you sure that Catalina designed this one? I think that Frank finally blew one... (O Boy! I bet this stirs up a hornet' nest...<img src=icon_smile_wink.gif border=0 align=middle>) Derek, who is very happy with his C25<img src=icon_smile_big.gif border=0 align=middle>
My current one, at the suggestion of Catalina Direct, is not the metal cable from Catalina but one of the super fiber lines I purchased through West Marine. It looks like it will last this season at least.
<BLOCKQUOTE id=quote><font size=1 face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica" id=quote>quote:<hr height=1 noshade id=quote> With all the problems that you C250 owners have with the steering, the rudder, the outboard, the centerboard etc. - are you sure that Catalina designed this one? I think that Frank finally blew one... (O Boy! I bet this stirs up a hornet' nest...<img src=icon_smile_wink.gif border=0 align=middle>) Derek, who is very happy with his C25<img src=icon_smile_big.gif border=0 align=middle>
Other than the rounding up problem which was solved by the new rudder we've had no problems with our '97 wing keel. That said, one of the reasons we went with the wing keel (since we don't trailer) was to avoid all the moving parts issues.
I'm much more concerned with the fact that Catalina doesn't seem to have addressed the problem adequately. <img src=icon_smile_shock.gif border=0 align=middle> I hope this is not a sign of things to come at Catalina.
Don’t pay any attention to Derek. He’s just stirring the pot. I love my C-25 too, but C-25’s had problems with excessive rudder pressure, leaky windows, swing keel hardware, improper balance and unreliable thru-hulls. I don’t see that the C-250 has any more problems than any other boat of new design. I like my Saturn automobile, but it needed a valve job at 12,000 miles. I liked my previous Honda, but it had premature transmission problems and cv joint problems. We live in a world of complex design problems. One thing I especially like about Catalina is that, unlike other manufacturers, they never seem to quit helping us find solutions to some of these problems.
Thank you for all of your comments. I kept the initial mssg brief. In fact my dealer has had this boat four times over the last two years (incluidng the final delivery in August 02). As I keep the boat on Lake Michigan near my 2nd home, it is a 500 mile round trip from my main home to the boat and then to the dealer and then home. I also took the boat to a local marine shop whose reponse to the systme was that it was "cheap" They looked to see of the blocks were in alignment and they were. They did think that the grooves in the block were small and the wire could jump out but we made no change. We tried to replace the "ball" fitting with a "t" fitting to see if that would help and it did not. Now I find out about a third rudder. I gave up racing the boat as it was too hard to steer up wind close hauled in 12-15 kts. How can a manufacturer not notify current owners of the issue and then charge for the replacment. It was bad enough that I had to discover the first solution on this site and then pay freight to send my first rudder back. Where is Ralph Nader when you need him? Based on the past history of not fixing my problems and with the rudder response, I anticipate problems in getting this resolved. Are there any other recurring issues with this design that I need to know about. I really like the boat - just wish that it is what I ordered. By the way I worked in the automotive industry and my wife is a design engineer for Ford. Neither the rudder nor the wire problem is one that should have occured originally nor taken very long to fix -we are not talking about a 12 valve fuel injection motor. Tks for all of your help.
I guess a wing Keel is obviously less maintainence, but I can tell you for sure. You do not want to trailor a wing keel very often. If trailoring is your thing then managing the maintainence is simple compared to trying to do maintain your boat in a slip. The one thing that every sailor repeated to me was that every sailboat is a set of compromises. You can't have everything. If you want a racer then you give up certain comforts, If you want a cruiser then you give up speed, if you want a 25' boat that is easy to trailor then you give up other things like head room or certain sailing features. Every sailor has his/her priorities. Boat ownership is a quest to find the boat that is the right answer for the individual sailor and his/her goals. This experience is just helping you make that next step towards the boat that is right for your needs and pleasure. At this point I am absoutely thrilled with my 250WK, BUT in just a few years I know that I will be looking for that next boat.....I know one thing for sure...I would not maintain or keep a boat that would not allow me to enjoy sailing when I had the free time to go especially when there are so many choices out on the market, there is a sailor somewhere that would love to have your boat and would find the perfect solution to the problem.....there are lots of choices, just make one. Steve Steakley Moon Chaser 250 WK #385
For those who may have followed the Trailor Sailor forumn over the years.... a perspective resulted that all the manufacturers of water ballast boats got caught unaware of rudder lift requirements. The hull design for water ballast is new...
Important is that Catalina has worked with the owners, freight charges and "at cost" are much more than no support at all...and thats what the others manufactures offered... none.
Steve is right, all new designs have bugs and problems to resolve. The c250 was a totally new design in '95. The C25 had its problems as well, it had an unbalanced rudder as well when first released, the swing keel was terminated because of excess damage and possible safety issues, the headstay stem fitting was inadequately supported on many of earlier production....etc.
Not that I'm not surprized a bit by Catalina... the original rudder on the c250 was of balanced design... though it had inadequate lift... why they produced the second unbalanced is a mystery.
Catalina did make some mods to the center board cable..., they have made many other mods to the c250 in efforts to refine the design. I believe Frank Butler speaks sincerely when he says that Catalina endeavors to give customers the best possible at a reasonable cost.
Notice: The advice given on this site is based upon individual or quoted experience, yours may differ. The Officers, Staff and members of this site only provide information based upon the concept that anyone utilizing this information does so at their own risk and holds harmless all contributors to this site.