Notice:
The advice given on this site is based upon individual or quoted experience, yours may differ.
The Officers, Staff and members of this site only provide information based upon the concept that anyone utilizing this information does so at their own risk and holds harmless all contributors to this site.
After literally months of searching and researching on the internet, I am 99.9% sure I want a Catalina 25 or 250. Lately, I am thinking the 250WB. In fact soon I will be making a trek out of state to check out three boats: a Cat 250WK, a Cat 250WB and a Cat 25WK.
Each boat seems to have its advantages and disadvantages. I have read what feels like EVERY string on this website's forums just to make myself as informed as possible.
In some ways I actually hope when I "test drive" the three boats that I won't notice a difference in performance so that the choice in my case is easy. I will choose the one that is most trailerable. I will not be mooring my boat at all. I will always trailer it.
So that means, with a draft of only 1'8", the water ballast is my choice. It seems like it has all the advantages of motorboating as far as launching, light towing, etc. It also seems that the water ballast performs just fine if not better that a lead or cast iron weighted keel sailboat. In fact, some of you swear by it. Like I said, I have read most of the strings that relate to comparisons of the different styles.
What I am having trouble wrapping my little structural engineering brain around is the physics involved with the water ballast. I think I can readily understand the physics involved with the wing keel, for example, as a sort of balance/counter-balance thing. Or if you know what a moment is, then a positive moment/negative moment thing where the force of the wind against the sails is being countered by the weight of the keel, tending to help keep the boat upright.
The lead is used in the keel due to its high density. It is way heavier than the water it is displacing creating a weight advantage right there. Plus, just the configuration of the wing keel places the weight further from the bottom of the boat, developing a larger lever arm which creates a mechanical advantage.
The water ballast doesn't seem to do either of these things. The water in the ballast is the same density as the water outside (of course) and the ballast tanks are as close to the bottom of the boat as you can get.
I can visualize somewhat that the fact the boat is sitting lower in the water when the tanks are filled helps in stabilization. But for some reason I can't quite grasp what set of principles the water ballast works under.
If someone could please explain or point me to a reference that could explain, I would be very appreciative and more comfortable buying the Cat 250WB I am going to look at in a couple of weeks. Which, by the way, couldn't come soon enough. I am very excited.
Jim: here is a link from an article posted on the trailor sailor website about this topic. http://www.trailersailor.com/content/features/index.cgi?read=14 Hope you find it useful. I have trailered my 250 WB many times for some treks of over 500 miles, as has many other people on this forum. The boat and trailer have been no problem to trailer. The launching and retreival (including mast raising and lowering and rigging)so far is taking me about 3 hours. I am confident this can be reduced to at least 2hr. or less.
Jim, you have reopened a can of worms that saw considerable discussion, here and on the Trailer Sailor forumn. Most of that discussion on the C25/250 forumn is lost as it was on a previous platform.
When first introduced... most of us didn't understand the dynamics...and with initial handling problems...water ballast boats took hits that slowed acceptance.
Some of those issues are still revelant..some have been debunked. Likely, the largest, was that water was an ineffectual ballast medium...because of equal density and therefore not providing righting stability until the ballast tank rose above the boats water line leaving a zone of initial tenderness.
It's now understood that the water ballast displaces air within the hull to provide righting... and the difference between air and water is somewhat as significant as lead and water.
To assist the interior ballast (with its shorter righting arm....the arm distance is increased by (squaring the bilges) a flatter and wider bottom which serves two purposes... It places the water ballast wider from the center line...and it provides increased form stability.
There are trade offs for the benefits... among them, the wider flatter hull form is subject to increased weather helm with heel. To increase righting stability, freeboard is increased by doing away with the sidedecks but subjects the boat to more windage.
The result however, is a boat that can literally be launched and retrieved at any ramp suitable for power boats and done almost as easy with no need for tounge extenders, ropes and dollies...etc. Occassionally, I've had to discharge the ballast (easy to pump out with an air mattress pump)to retreive...
Among the negatives are the mechanical considerations of the centerboard and the loss of interior headroom consumed by the ballast tank. The center board however in my opinion is an overall plus compared to the wing...providing better windward sailing performance...and greater ability to balance the helm.
Per your requirement to trailer only... the water ballast is the boat designed to do that well. I have trailered mine the last five years from Texas to the upper Great Lakes and North Channel and cruised it 1,500 miles in a variety of conditons... Also, a cruise to Pensacola, Fl two years ago and contemplating the April 2003 Trailor Sailor flotilla to the Bahamas.
Let me preface this by saying I have a fin keel C25. I think where the trouble is that people have is a basic misunderstanding of the water ballast boat. When I first thought of I think people automatically think of a soda, beer can that has fallen in the water. As you watch it slowly drift away you can see it spin. There is no stability in this situation. What the water balast boat does is confine the weight of the water at one end. Back to the analogies. My son always leaves the beach ball in the pool. It seams that one side alway is up and the other down. This is due to variations in the thickness of the wall. Thick is heaver and therefore down. The same thing happens with a boat. The water is trapped on the bottom and therefore makes that side stay down. I don't know if any of you have a fish tank, but I can tell you water is heavy. Not as heavy as iron or lead, but still heavy. The reading I have done says that to have the same righting ability as a keel boat the water balast has to be very large. Again from what I have read WB boats have a higher floor to account for this. I have not sailed on a WB boat, but have sailed by them and I think that they are probably stable enough for most conditions. I have the keel boat because the admrial wants the MOST stable possible. If I were you I would opt for the WB to do the trailering you want to do. I take mine to different places, but we had to get a 1 ton pickup and it is a pain to climb up on the top step of an eight foot ladder. Still love my boat <img src=icon_smile.gif border=0 align=middle>
I have trailored my wing Keel twice, once to take out and once to put back in (for a bottom job), about a 70 mile trip one way. I would not want to trailor this boat again. You have to have a 20' strap or tounge extension and for sure a 1 ton truck to get it out, or a 3/4 ton 4 wheel drive for steep slippery ramps. If you are going to trailor there is only 1 choice and that would be a WB for sure, Steve Steakley Moon Chaser #385 WK
Jim: If you intend to only trailer the boat, the WB is the only choice (in my opinion). I've owned my '95 250WB #163 for three seasons and only this season have had it in a slip. The previous 2 years we trailered the boat all over Idaho, to numerous high mt. lakes and ramps of various condition, slope, depth etc. If your boating on a reservoir, the condition of the ramp will likely change as the water level changes, so an easliy launched and recovered boat is VERY important. The WB launches and recovers just as easily as a 20' family outbiard runabout. I pull the boat with a 1/2 ton short bed 1993 GMC pickup. It's rare to even have to back in far enough to get the rear wheels in the water,(ramp slope being the factor). I don't know which flavor of the 250 is faster, I suspect they are similar if all points of sail are taken into account. I do know that our boat is a delight to sail and if we tend to triming well in a race, we're competitive against the C25's.
Andy Anderson CSCO Kid C250WB #163 MHYC McCall, Idaho P
Jim: Regarding your question regarding density, let's try this...
You have a flat-bottomed boat that is sitting level in the water. You put a cement block on one side of the centerline, and it tips. You take out the cement block and put a bucket of water on one side of the centerline, and it tips again. You take that out and put a large log (which will float in water) in the same spot, and it tips. You take that out and put a big tractor innertube full of air, which will practically float on the surface) upright on that side of the boat, and the boat tips again. Even a wine cork will tip it a little.
The density of the material inside the hull matters only in that the greater weight affects the center of gravity more as heeling moves it away from the center of boyancy, which is mostly a factor of the hull width and shape. Back to the water bucket: If you put a second identical bucket on the opposite side, the boat returns to upright. If you pull on the mast (OK, new component), it resists the pull because the center of gravity is moving one way (away from the pull) while the center of boyancy is moving the other (toward the deeper side of the hull). The leward bucket is closer to the center of boyancy, and the windward bucket is further away. The further away from the centerline, the more the buckets will cause the CG shift as the boat heels--thus Arlyn's point about broader, flatter hulls.
Another point to ponder... If you dump the water out of the buckets into the bottom of the boat, all of this reverses! As the boat tips, the water flows to the low side and does nothing to right the boat. I suspect that a half-full water ballast tank will have less initial stability (up to maybe 45 degrees) than than an empty one! But a full tank holds the water in place, forcing the CG to windward as the boat heels.
Sorry... I'll go back to the C-25 forum with my lead keel. I just got interested in this issue when I was first looking for a 25-footer, back when some people here were arguing that water ballast couldn't work unless the internal water rose above the waterline. That debate actually got a little ugly! <img src=icon_smile_dissapprove.gif border=0 align=middle>
Dave Bristle - 1985 C-25 #5032 SR-FK-Dinette-Honda "Passage" in SW CT
Notice: The advice given on this site is based upon individual or quoted experience, yours may differ. The Officers, Staff and members of this site only provide information based upon the concept that anyone utilizing this information does so at their own risk and holds harmless all contributors to this site.