Notice:
The advice given on this site is based upon individual or quoted experience, yours may differ.
The Officers, Staff and members of this site only provide information based upon the concept that anyone utilizing this information does so at their own risk and holds harmless all contributors to this site.
Thank goodness for my dealer. He has provided me with a retro-fit cable kit from Catalina that is supposed to cure the cable snapping problem. It replaces the steel cable with some kind of non-stretching line, and the wire guide block under the companionway gets replaced with a Harken single block.
I had the boat hauled out yesterday for a bottom job, and while on the blocks, I'll be installing the modification. I'll shoot some pictures and get them to Mark for Tech Tips posting.
Tray is Catalina paying for this modification? Also do you know if Catalina considers this a design modification that they will make the change to on any WB 250 still under warantee.
I'm not sure if Catalina is paying for it, or if my dealer is. I am not. Unless you count my labor.
My boat is still under warranty, but I believe Catalina should treat this as a recall for everyone, just like an automaker would. I'll find out more info from my dealer Monday, and post it here.
The new clasp has some bushings with it, but pin isn't long enough to hold the bushings and pass through the centerboard, and I had limited time in the slings, so...I took the clasp apart and flipped it around. It just fit without the bushings. I don't think Catalina fully tested this modification before they sent it out, unless the eyelet width on centerboards has changed since 2001. <img src="http://im1.shutterfly.com/procserv/47b2d708b3127cce90956493a27f0000001410" border=0>
The instructions are pretty clear. Other than the clasp size, the only difficulty I had was getting the new synthetic cable through the brass ball valve. I found a coat hanger and straightened it, then used it to poke the line into the conduit and into the cabin. Here is a picture of the board fully retracted: <img src="http://im1.shutterfly.com/procserv/47b2d708b3127cce90957867a2850000001410" border=0>
I forgot who was asking about the new rudder length compared to the retracted centerboard, but this is a pretty good indicator that the rudder is not longer than the board.
I'll get a tech tip submitted soon, but in the meantime, I thought this would help somebody else.
BTW, doesn't my bottom job look good. I only had to pay for the haul out (110.00) and the paint (140.00). Can't wait to splash in the morning!<img src=icon_smile_big.gif border=0 align=middle>
The new mod didn't work out so well. Overnight, with the boat still in the slings, the new cable unraveled and the centerboard fell. Luckily there was no damage. I had to splash the boat today, or pay storage fees, so I tied the line back onto the centerboard with a bowline.<img src=icon_smile_blackeye.gif border=0 align=middle>
I'm going to have to haul again in a couple weeks when I have time and fix this thing myself. I think if I use some high-quality stainless cable and a better clasp than the factory version, I might get it to last more than a few months.
When I had Desi I had a new cable made at Indusco on Talyrand Ave. just about below the Mathews Bridge here in Jville. All stainless w/ clevis pressed on at 30 tons or some huge figure. It was done while I waited.
Tray, at this point, Im going to have a beer and just meditate on your sorrows. Hey If it were me, after all you have gone thru, I would call Frank Butler direct and wait on the phone til he answered. I would not settle for talking to anyone else, I would fax him the precise documentation of each breakage and the time and cost involved. I would certainly be pleasant, but firm....I would ask what yard he would recommend in my area, and when exactly I should expect his representative or mechanic to show up. I would tell him what the yard will charge Catalina for the haul out. I would let him know how much you have and expect to enjoy this boat, and yet what a dissapointment this particular problem has caused your family and fellow Catalina owners. I understand that Mr. Butler is a good man, who is very proud of his product. I can't imagine that he would refuse.......because if he does.....He will get a letter from every Catalina 250 owner on this board, including myself,,,,and that would certainly ruin his week. Please continue to keep us informed, because we all fear that we're next.
I called my dealer yesterday about all this, and he gave me a number to call at Catalina. I spoke with someone named Kent. He designed this new mod. I gave him my feedback, and explained my dissatisfaction with the support I have received so far. He promised me that this new mod is going to last, and told me to submit a warranty repair request through my dealer to get the haul out fees reimbursed.
Notice: The advice given on this site is based upon individual or quoted experience, yours may differ. The Officers, Staff and members of this site only provide information based upon the concept that anyone utilizing this information does so at their own risk and holds harmless all contributors to this site.