Notice:
The advice given on this site is based upon individual or quoted experience, yours may differ.
The Officers, Staff and members of this site only provide information based upon the concept that anyone utilizing this information does so at their own risk and holds harmless all contributors to this site.
I am close to deciding between a Catalina 250 water ballast and a 22-MKII with retractable keel. I would like the larger 250 but have some reservations about towing and launching/loading the boat single handed or with one other person. I live in WV (lots of hills and mountains). I drive a Jeep Grand Cherokee with the 6 cyl engine - it has a towing package on (trans cooler, tow hitch and other beef ups). I am about 200 miles from the Chesapeake and about an hour from serveral large lakes. Questions: 1. How practical is it to tow the 250 that far and launch/load it?? The beast looks huge on the trailer compared to the 22-MKII. 2. Is the Jeep enough to tow it? 3. Or should I just get the 250 wing keel and park it in the Chesapeake and do the weekend shuffle? Thanks for any opions or comments you wish to share
Frank.. I tow my 250WB in the mountains of Idaho with a GMC short bed pickup with a mildly souped up 305 V8 with no problems except on the steepest grades (we sometimes get down to 30mph on those). The boat trailers beautifully and the factory trail-right trailer is superb. I almost bought a C22mk II as well. I'm extremely happy with the 250 and am very happy we went with the bigger boat. The extra room is worth it especially if you have kids. I think if you check, you'll find that the swing c22 weighs almost as much as the 250WB. I don't know for sure but I think they're fairly close. I can't tell you if the jeep is enough rig for either. I consider my truck marginal because of the short wheel base and relatively light weight. If you plan on boating exclusively on the Chesapeake, I'd buy a fixed keel boat in a slip over there and drive. If you plan on trailering to different lakes or sail on a close lake, the 250WB would be the choice. Remember, you've got your travel time plus about 1.5 to 3 hours of setup, takedown, and launch time to figure into your day.
Andy Anderson CSCO Kid C250WB #163 MYYC McCall, Idaho
I agree with Andy. I started looking at the 22, but found a deal on a 250WB. I have trailered it twice since I bought it last year. I would not recommend it if you were planning to trailer and set up/take down every weekend, unless you enjoyed erector sets as a kid. Set up and rigging took me 2 hours, and tuning the mast took another hour. Taking everything down only takes about an hour. I bought it because the Navy could transfer me anytime, and it would be easy to take with me, but also because I hope to trailer it to distant, far away sailing grounds when I get the time off. I may not ever get to do so, but the freedom to be able to is nice.
My tow vehicle is a 99 Ford F-150, V8, and I have no trouble. I think the dry weight of the boat is 3K, and I think my trailer weighs close to 1K. Make sure your Jeep can handle 5K before making your decision, or be willing to get a bigger truck. I traded my VW Beetle for my F-150 once I decided on the C250.
I definitely recommend the biggest boat you can afford that fits your use. I looked at the 22, Hunter 240 and 260, and a Mac 26X <img src=icon_smile_dead.gif border=0 align=middle> before settling on the 250. As far as WK vs. WB...there are many debates on this forum regarding which is better, but I think it depends on how you intend to use the boat. I like knowing that I can put it on a trailer anytime and move it where I want (as long as the centerboard cable is still connected). I also recommend reading "Sailing Big on a Small Sailboat" by Jerry Cardwell.
Finally...if I were going to buy a boat that would be in the water all the time and never trailered, I would buy something in the 28-30ft range, used. Something else to think about...if you buy a 250 or an old 25, you'll have the help and support of this forum, which has been very good to me, as a first time boat owner.
Good luck...one last thought...that old saying about the 2 happiest days in a boat owners life...The day he buys the boat and the day he sells it, is not true. Everytime I get out on the water in good wind on a cool day, and then drop the anchor and have dinner with the crew is far better than the day I bought it, especially if we get to spend the night.<img src=icon_smile.gif border=0 align=middle>
<b>1. How practical is it to tow the 250 that far and launch/load it?? The beast looks huge on the trailer compared to the 22-MKII. 2. Is the Jeep enough to tow it? 3. Or should I just get the 250 wing keel and park it in the Chesapeake and do the weekend shuffle?" - Frank</b>
Before deciding on a boat style you should probably determine where you will be sailing and how often.
Unless you are planning on sailing only a couple of times a year, it is just not practical to tow, setup, launch, retrieve, breakdown, and tow home a boat of this size on a frequent basis. I don't know how many days I sailed this season(I'm guessing 60 to 70 times), but if I had to tow and setup each time, believe me, the boat would have spent the majority of the summer in my backyard.
Since you are some distance from a sailing area, you may want to look into dry storage. When in dry storage you can leave the boat at the marina fully rigged on the trailer ready-to-go.
Another option, of course, is to rent a slip or mooring. This is more expensive, but the most convenient. You are already on the water rarin' to go.
Welcome to the forum! I played the same debate nearly a year ago myself. Through the many inputs of the friendly, knowledgeable people here at the association, I finally decided on a 250 WB. The WK was just much more than I wanted to try to deal with for a launch off of the trailer (suitable ramps in my area and the fact that I usually am basically single-handing were the concerns). Early on my wife ruled out the C-22 (way too small for her and the two kids, especially if we were to spend the night).
The WB so far has been very easy to launch/recover. I can do it totally by myself with no trouble at all. Not any harder than launching a powerboat of comparable size. Completely destepping the mast and putting the boat "to bed" for trailering down the road, however, is a time-consuming, if not difficult task. It CAN be done solo, but is MUCH easier with assistance. I ditto the comment that if I had to go through the process each time, I wouldn't sail very often. I've done the dry-slip and wet. Dry-slipping (fully rigged on the trailer) really isn't too bad. I'm trying to decide right now if I want to go back to dry-slipping or spring for a bottom job and keep her in a wet slip.
I tow 'Ruah' with a 99 4wd Suburban with towing package. Some pretty good hills here in central Texas, but have no problems. However, the ramp at the marina is pretty darned steep and slick. If I did not have four-wheel drive and the ramp was the slightest bit wet (which it usually is) I don't think I could pull her out of the water. As it is, I usually pop the drain plug and pull her out just far enough to drain the ballast tank, then continue up the ramp. The reduction of a few hundred pounds of water seems to help.
Didn't mean to ramble, but that's my two cents worth. Good luck, let us know if we can be of any help!<img src=icon_smile_big.gif border=0 align=middle>
Bren Peterson C250WB, #642, "Ruah" San Antonio, TX
Notice: The advice given on this site is based upon individual or quoted experience, yours may differ. The Officers, Staff and members of this site only provide information based upon the concept that anyone utilizing this information does so at their own risk and holds harmless all contributors to this site.