Notice:
The advice given on this site is based upon individual or quoted experience, yours may differ.
The Officers, Staff and members of this site only provide information based upon the concept that anyone utilizing this information does so at their own risk and holds harmless all contributors to this site.
An inspection of my single cable system shows no sign of problems at the turn radius coming out of the pedestal... but its doubtful that wear within the cable could be detected until just prior to a failure. There is a residue of black dust that Doug described under the aft end of cable.
Also inspected was the wheel turn ratio... it is 5/8 from center to rudder lock.
Examination of the pedestal base area from underneath shows probable space to enlarge the hole making room for two three inch sheaves to be mounted on an axle. The axle would need a bend at the center to aim the sheaves towards the quarters. There may even be space to dato the axle into the floor which would minimize sheave penetration into the berth.
Routing of cables for an open cable system looks to be very straightforward with only a couple of notches needed in the aft bulkhead.
Existing bolts for stern hardware may even provide the necessary anchoring for the quartering sheaves.
Sheaves present the greatest concern... marine sheaves being very expensive. Cost would need to be considerably less than the $512 Edson wants for the pull pull cable upgrade.
Yesterday while at Lowes Home Center I spotted some sheaves in the garage door secton that look to be acceptable. They are Genie door hardware items. They are not cast... but look very rugged with deep grooves, ball bearings, heavy riveting and are galvinized. And, they come in just the right sizes of three and four inchers. And, the price is right.... the three inchers are under $4 dollars and the four inchers are under $5. Their mount and axle is simple but rugged making them look very suitable for this project...excepting perhaps for a boat in a continuous salt water environment.
Because the sheaves are so inexpensive, two additional four inchers could be used at the rudder actuator arm to cascade to a 2/1 ratio and still keep project cost for entire at less than $50.
More investigation about wheel ratio is needed however... for example...any auto pilot limits. The existing chain if used, would it be long enough for 1.25 turns compared to existing 0.625?
Since the last post about alternatives to the Edson upgrade, I received communication from a wing owner who's boat was delivered with the pull pull system... and he modified to an open cable system.
His reasons were that he didn't like the play and considered it had too much drag under heavier loads. He designed and constructed a very nice system using a quadrant that has no play or drag. He used sheaves from Home Depot... looking exactly like the ones I described seeing at Lowes Home Center. He had the benefit of a machine shop.
His system did place a slight twisting load on the steering arm which would make removing the rudder difficult unless the steering cables were relaxed by adjusting the easily accessible turnbuckles.
I might add, his pictures showed also that he had made three large cut outs on the aft bulkhead and having removed the battery from that area, opened it up nicely to storage. The extra inches of aft berth height in the wing are great.
As for my steering plans... I'm leaning towards using a bell crank design as it would provide easy steering ratio adjustments and present no problems to removing the rudder.
Notice: The advice given on this site is based upon individual or quoted experience, yours may differ. The Officers, Staff and members of this site only provide information based upon the concept that anyone utilizing this information does so at their own risk and holds harmless all contributors to this site.